Leadership Insights Series: Hire for the Culture You Want to Build – A Conversation with Growth Advisor Megan Dimmer

Growth advisor and former CEO Megan Dimmer on why the hiring process is where sales culture is won or lost.

Few people have seen the sales process from as many angles as Megan Dimmer. She started in sales at Lexmark, spending fifteen years learning what it actually takes to build a high-performing team within a large, structured organization. From there, she moved into the world of AEC, taking on progressively larger roles at Humphreys & Partners until she became CEO of one of the world’s largest multifamily architecture firms. It was not a ceremonial title. She was running a $70M business with 450 people across multiple countries, no small feat.

For the past seven years, she has primarily worked as a growth advisor and fractional CRO, partnering with CEOs at AEC and professional services firms who are serious about building revenue that holds. During that time, she has also advised select technology startups, bringing a broad perspective on growth strategy and execution. She offers something most advisors cannot: firsthand experience building and scaling revenue from the inside, across a wide range of organizations and business environments.

When you ask Megan Dimmer about sales culture, she’ll bring you back to hiring pretty quickly. Not because culture doesn’t matter, but because in her experience, it’s rarely the root of the problem. Culture is what happens downstream. The real question is whether the organization hired the right people, built the right structure around them, and gave them expectations they could actually meet. Get those things right, and culture tends to take care of itself. Get them wrong, and no culture initiative will save you.

Ask the harder question first

Before organizations even start thinking about who to hire, Dimmer pushes them to answer a more fundamental question: Is a new sales leader the solution to the problem? “The expectation is often that the sales leader is going to outsell a broken operating model,” she says. When compensation is misaligned, KPIs are murky, and internal processes are a mess, a new hire walks into a situation that was already set up to fail.

If the model is solid, the next question is specificity. Does the organization need someone to build a sales function from scratch? Rebuild and clean it up? Chase new logos? Grow existing accounts? Each scenario calls for a different kind of leader, and lumping all of it into one generic job description is one of the most common places organizations lose time.

Be honest about the timeline

Dimmer sees a pattern that plays out repeatedly: board or investor pressure gets passed down as unrealistic expectations for the new hire. It never ends well. A strong revenue leader simply cannot compress a 24-month sales cycle to four. Organizations that expect otherwise are setting both the leader and themselves up for a failed search.

“You set yourself up for failure as an organization, and you set your new leader up for failure, when you’re expecting miracles. Look at your historical sales cycle. Don’t expect that to change overnight just because you’ve hired someone great.”

Proof over promise

When interviewing prospective sales leaders, Dimmer applies one standard: proof over promise. Candidates will tell you what you want to hear. What she looks for is whether they can walk through the specifics of how they’ve done the thing you need, and whether the references confirm the same story. She looks for input from a manager, a peer, and a direct report. When all three are pointing in the same direction, you’re on solid ground.

“If a leader is great at what they do, everyone around them knows it. When three different parties are all telling the same story, you’re much more likely to be on target.”

She also cautions against the halo effect. A candidate who spent their career at well-known companies can be easy to get excited about, but the more useful question is whether they’ve ever had to perform without a strong brand behind them. Have they sold the product nobody’s heard of, or only the one that sells itself?

Culture follows; it does not lead

Dimmer’s five pillars are strategy, structure, people, systems, and culture. The order is intentional. Culture sits at the end because it is what surfaces when the other four are working well together. That means a strategy that is clearly communicated and connected to company goals. A structure with the right roles in the right places and real accountability built in. Compensation that rewards collaboration, not just individual performance. And people who have shown they can work that way, not just people who say they can.

“Working together as a team always gets you there more quickly, and in a way that’s replicable and repeatable. When you have the pillars in place and you’re holding people accountable for collaboration, that’s when real culture forms.”

One thing no framework replaces, she says, is people being in contact with each other. Even on distributed teams, the habit of sharing what’s working, what isn’t, and how a deal got closed is what keeps everyone rowing the same direction.

Leadership Insights is a series by Buffkin / Baker that profiles exceptional leaders across industries. To nominate a leader for a future interview or to speak with our team about a senior executive search, we’d love to hear from you.

Follow us on LinkedIn to stay up to date with the latest thought leadership.